Wedding Cakes

Thoughtfully designed, beautifully crafted, and made to be remembered.

At Sincerely, Sarah, we create bespoke wedding cakes that reflect the beauty and individuality of your celebration.  From romantic, garden-inspired designs to sculptural buttercream and delicate hand-painted details, each cake is thoughtfully created with an artistic eye and a refined, timeless aesthetic.

Made entirely from scratch with carefully sourced ingredients, our cakes are designed to be as memorable in flavor as they are in appearance.

Beautiful Inside & Out

Every cake begins with exceptional flavor. We use carefully sourced ingredients to create tender cakes, beautifully balanced fillings, and buttercreams made from scratch.

From timeless vanilla and rich chocolate to seasonal fruit fillings and more distinctive flavor combinations, each cake is thoughtfully composed to complement your celebration.

Wedding cake tastings are available by arrangement for couples wishing to explore our flavors before making their selections.

Our Process

01 | Your Inquiry

Tell us a little about your celebration, including your wedding date, venue, guest count, and any design inspiration you may have.  We’ll discuss your vision and availability.

02 | Design & Details

Together, we’ll explore cake flavors, fillings, size, and design details. From delicate florals to hand-painted and sculptural elements, each cake is thoughtfully designed to complement your celebration.

03 | Your Wedding Day

Your cake is handcrafted with care, using thoughtfully sourced ingredients and an unwavering attention to detail.  Wedding cake delivery and professional setup are available, with arrangements coordinated in advance to ensure your cake is beautifully presented and ready for your celebration.

Let's Create Something Beautiful

We would love to hear about your celebration.  Share a few details about your wedding, along with any design inspiration you may have.  We look forward to creating something beautiful for your day.

Serving weddings throughout Pittsburgh and the surrounding areas.

Inquire About Your Wedding Cake