Signature Cake Collection
A curated collection of cakes designed in the signature style of Sincerely, Sarah.
Thoughtfully crafted with exceptional ingredients, refined buttercream work, and seasonal inspiration, each design is available in a selection of sizes and personalized with your choice of filling.
Beautifully suited for birthdays, showers, anniversaries, and meaningful gatherings.
Intentional Ingredients
Every ingredient is chosen as thoughtfully as every design.
We source locally whenever possible, partnering with nearby farms for fresh eggs, milk, butter, cream, yogurt, sour cream, raw honey, seasonal fruit, and edible flowers. Summer fruit is preserved at peak ripeness so its flavor can be enjoyed long after the season has passed.
Our recipes are made without artificial preservatives, stabilizers, or unnecessary additives. Sugar is used to enhance, never overpower, allowing natural flavors to remain the focus.
Even the water used in every recipe is filtered through our Berkey system because exceptional ingredients deserve the same level of care from beginning to end.
Because beautiful cakes begin with beautiful ingredients.
Custom Cakes
Every custom cake begins with your celebration and is thoughtfully designed to reflect your story, style, and the moments that matter most.
From delicate buttercream work and seasonal florals to hand-painted artwork and sculptural details, every cake is crafted from scratch using thoughtfully sourced ingredients and finished with refined buttercream work.
Experience Our Signature Flavors
Explore our Signature Petite Cake Collection—a curated tasting experience designed to help you discover your favorite cake and filling combinations before your celebration.
From the Pâtisserie
All of our breads, croissants, rolls, and yeasted pastries are crafted using our house sourdough starter alongside traditional baker’s yeast.
This slow, natural fermentation develops deeper flavor, refined texture, and greater digestibility. We never use bleached or brominated flour, and allowing the dough to ferment gently creates baked goods that feel lighter and thoughtfully made.
Time, patience, and intention are among the most important ingredients in everything we bake.
Find Us This Season
Find us at these upcoming events and markets
Mars Farmers Market
Across from the Mars post office
Pine Farmers Market
Near the baseball fields